Victims of some of the most notorious corruption cases in Pennsylvania and Illinois are speaking out after President Joe Biden granted clemency to two convicted officials as part of a broader clemency package this week. The announcement, which included commutations for nearly 1,500 individuals, has drawn sharp criticism, with victims arguing that the decision undermines justice.
The two officials at the center of the backlash—former Pennsylvania Judge Michael Conahan and a convicted Illinois fraudster—had already been released from prison early due to the Covid-19 pandemic. Both were serving house arrest, which Biden’s clemency now terminates entirely.
'Kids for Cash' victim reacts after Biden commutes sentence for Pennsylvania judge https://t.co/b30EicDXWr
— FOX 5 San Diego (@fox5sandiego) December 13, 2024
An administration official explained that the commutations were granted under uniform criteria, such as good behavior while on house arrest, and were not case-specific. However, that explanation has done little to ease the anger of those affected by Conahan’s actions in what remains one of the darkest judicial scandals in Pennsylvania history.
Michael Conahan was convicted in 2011 for his role in the infamous “kids-for-cash” scandal. He and another Luzerne County judge accepted kickbacks from for-profit juvenile detention centers in exchange for sentencing children to their facilities. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ultimately overturned 4,000 juvenile convictions tied to the corrupt judges’ misconduct, and the two were ordered to pay $200 million in damages to victims.
Conahan’s original sentence was cut short during the pandemic, and he had been set to remain on house arrest until 2026. Biden’s commutation ends that punishment, effectively closing the book on one of the most egregious cases of judicial corruption in U.S. history. Victims and their families say the clemency decision denies them the closure and justice they deserve.
Critics argue that the decision reflects a broader trend of controversial clemency actions under Biden’s administration. The president has already faced bipartisan criticism for pardoning his son, Hunter Biden, following his conviction on multiple tax and gun charges earlier this year.
For many, the clemency granted to Conahan and others undermines the accountability that victims of these crimes fought to achieve. One Pennsylvania victim shared their frustration, calling the decision “a slap in the face to everyone who suffered because of him.”
While the White House defends the clemency package as an opportunity for “second chances,” victims of these high-profile cases see it as a failure to prioritize justice. The clemency has reopened wounds for those who continue to grapple with the impact of the crimes committed by these officials.
